IMPORTANT: due to people using bots to scrape the website data, we have to restrict the access to the races only to people with an account. We hope that for now this will be temporay.
IMPORTANT: Routing and Elevation API are limited to 7000 calls per day. In case they are expired, they won't work until limit is re-charged. You can try in this case to do a GPX on RideWithGPS site and import it on the editor
Please don't spam us mail and PMs that we won't answer and notice that the official language of forum is English.
Comment with us the races in the Telegram Chat
New Contest Season is on: Contest 3
Follow us on Twitter: @laflammerouge16
New Feature: 3d maps - To activate it, follow this guide
IMPORTANT: Routing and Elevation API are limited to 7000 calls per day. In case they are expired, they won't work until limit is re-charged. You can try in this case to do a GPX on RideWithGPS site and import it on the editor
Please don't spam us mail and PMs that we won't answer and notice that the official language of forum is English.
Comment with us the races in the Telegram Chat
New Contest Season is on: Contest 3
Follow us on Twitter: @laflammerouge16
New Feature: 3d maps - To activate it, follow this guide
Tour de France 2018 - Voting
Moderator: Tracking Contests
- emmea90
- Consulente tattico Continental Tour
- Posts: 901
- Joined: 17/05/2011, 15:47
- Location: Milano
- Contact:
Tour de France 2018 - Voting
Contest #4 - Tour de France 2018 (Category 1) - Voting
In this topic you can vote for the Winter Stage Races, according to the following rules.
PLEASE READ ALL THE POST BEFORE VOTING
How to vote
1 - You have to judge the track according to the requirements. This time I'll link the topic because it's too long to quote. Check the post
2 - You have to write in a post your best FIVE routes, from worse to best, providing a brief motivation for each choice
- First choice got 6 points, second 4, third 3, fourth 2 and fifth 1 point.
- Presentation bonus grant you 3 points (we will add later with penalties who took the bonus)
- Ranking will be made according to points obtained
- In case of equality I will decide the winner
- YOU CAN'T VOTE FOR YOURSELF
- You can also comment other people's reviews regarding your or other one's routes
- YOU CAN'T CHANGE YOUR VOTE ONCE SUBMITTED
Who can vote?
- Every user that submitted a contest (full points vote)
- Every user in the La Flamme Rouge Staff (Emmea90, Pigna, Sagan99, Matthorse, Nasdon33, Linkinito, Bose12)
- Every user that has registered BEFORE 13 march 2018 and has at least 10 tracks in the editor. In this case, his votes counts half of the points scale
Penalties
- Every user that submitted a contest and doesn't submit a valid vote (with 5 choices and motivations) will get a 10 points penalty for all his routes.
- It's FORBBIDDEN to ask for votes. Who will be caught public or privately asking for a vote to some users will get a 50 points penalty in first instance, then the exclusion from all the contests of the year
- Vote penalties for unpracticable routes will be assigned by staff during this phase
Deadline for vote phase is 29 july 2018, h 23.59
Tracks:
Emilio.Torre-V1: maps/tours/view/8607
Alfa-V1: maps/tours/view/8645 +3 bonus
Ded-Moroz-V1: maps/tours/view/8660 +3 bonus
Anthofou31-V1: maps/tours/view/8677
Belgian4444-V1: maps/tours/view/8639 +3 bonus
Mauro-V1: maps/tours/view/8697
Xiky-V1: maps/tours/view/8754 +3 bonus
Pereiroseleccion-V1: maps/tours/view/8834
Anthofou31-V2: maps/tours/view/8759
Antoinvds-V1: maps/tours/view/8893 +3 bonus
DYDYDYDOU-V1: maps/tours/view/6065 +3 bonus
Benoit.guillout-V1: maps/tours/view/8954 +3 bonus
DYDYDYDOU-V2: maps/tours/view/9410 +3 bonus
RdZ1201-V1: maps/tours/view/8916 +3 bonus
Xander66-V1: maps/tours/view/8741 +3 bonus
Arnorius-V1: maps/tours/view/9562 +3 bonus
Kanon16-V1: maps/tours/view/9444 +3 bonus
Benoit.guillout-V2: maps/tours/view/9673 +3 bonus
Timonierop-V1: maps/tours/view/9207 +3 bonus
Pontix-V1: maps/tours/view/9592
JibiValverde-V1: maps/tours/view/8638
JibiValverde-V2: maps/tours/view/9749
Chiumiento-V1: maps/tours/view/9171
Antoinvds-V2: maps/tours/view/9907 +3 bonus
Bocmanis82-V1: maps/tours/view/9936 +3 bonus
Jaivar27-V1: maps/tours/view/9927 +3 bonus
Matklimmertje-V1: maps/tours/view/9279
Diego12Alpe-V1: maps/tours/view/8794 +3 bonus
Tomremn-V1: maps/tours/view/9960
Miere1985-V1: maps/tours/view/9469 +3 bonus
Laplaz-V1: maps/tours/view/9472 +3 bonus
Taaramae_Crack-V1: maps/tours/view/9967 +3 bonus
Kanon16-V2: maps/tours/view/9871 +3 bonus
Pincoletto-V1: maps/tours/view/9328
Metatron-V1: maps/tours/view/9594 +3 bonus
JAdmeal-V1: maps/tours/view/9979
Nebe-V1: maps/tours/view/9977 admitted with no bonus and -3 for late delivery
PLEASE ALWAYS SPECIFY THE VERSION OF THE ROUTE YOU VOTE FOR (1 or 2 WHERE AVAILABLE)
In this topic you can vote for the Winter Stage Races, according to the following rules.
PLEASE READ ALL THE POST BEFORE VOTING
How to vote
1 - You have to judge the track according to the requirements. This time I'll link the topic because it's too long to quote. Check the post
2 - You have to write in a post your best FIVE routes, from worse to best, providing a brief motivation for each choice
How does it work?FIFTH PLACE
(Motivation)
FOURTH PLACE
(Motivation)
THIRD PLACE
(Motivation)
SECOND PLACE
(Motivation)
FIRST PLACE
(Motivation)
- First choice got 6 points, second 4, third 3, fourth 2 and fifth 1 point.
- Presentation bonus grant you 3 points (we will add later with penalties who took the bonus)
- Ranking will be made according to points obtained
- In case of equality I will decide the winner
- YOU CAN'T VOTE FOR YOURSELF
- You can also comment other people's reviews regarding your or other one's routes
- YOU CAN'T CHANGE YOUR VOTE ONCE SUBMITTED
Who can vote?
- Every user that submitted a contest (full points vote)
- Every user in the La Flamme Rouge Staff (Emmea90, Pigna, Sagan99, Matthorse, Nasdon33, Linkinito, Bose12)
- Every user that has registered BEFORE 13 march 2018 and has at least 10 tracks in the editor. In this case, his votes counts half of the points scale
Penalties
- Every user that submitted a contest and doesn't submit a valid vote (with 5 choices and motivations) will get a 10 points penalty for all his routes.
- It's FORBBIDDEN to ask for votes. Who will be caught public or privately asking for a vote to some users will get a 50 points penalty in first instance, then the exclusion from all the contests of the year
- Vote penalties for unpracticable routes will be assigned by staff during this phase
Deadline for vote phase is 29 july 2018, h 23.59
Tracks:
Emilio.Torre-V1: maps/tours/view/8607
Alfa-V1: maps/tours/view/8645 +3 bonus
Ded-Moroz-V1: maps/tours/view/8660 +3 bonus
Anthofou31-V1: maps/tours/view/8677
Belgian4444-V1: maps/tours/view/8639 +3 bonus
Mauro-V1: maps/tours/view/8697
Xiky-V1: maps/tours/view/8754 +3 bonus
Pereiroseleccion-V1: maps/tours/view/8834
Anthofou31-V2: maps/tours/view/8759
Antoinvds-V1: maps/tours/view/8893 +3 bonus
DYDYDYDOU-V1: maps/tours/view/6065 +3 bonus
Benoit.guillout-V1: maps/tours/view/8954 +3 bonus
DYDYDYDOU-V2: maps/tours/view/9410 +3 bonus
RdZ1201-V1: maps/tours/view/8916 +3 bonus
Xander66-V1: maps/tours/view/8741 +3 bonus
Arnorius-V1: maps/tours/view/9562 +3 bonus
Kanon16-V1: maps/tours/view/9444 +3 bonus
Benoit.guillout-V2: maps/tours/view/9673 +3 bonus
Timonierop-V1: maps/tours/view/9207 +3 bonus
Pontix-V1: maps/tours/view/9592
JibiValverde-V1: maps/tours/view/8638
JibiValverde-V2: maps/tours/view/9749
Chiumiento-V1: maps/tours/view/9171
Antoinvds-V2: maps/tours/view/9907 +3 bonus
Bocmanis82-V1: maps/tours/view/9936 +3 bonus
Jaivar27-V1: maps/tours/view/9927 +3 bonus
Matklimmertje-V1: maps/tours/view/9279
Diego12Alpe-V1: maps/tours/view/8794 +3 bonus
Tomremn-V1: maps/tours/view/9960
Miere1985-V1: maps/tours/view/9469 +3 bonus
Laplaz-V1: maps/tours/view/9472 +3 bonus
Taaramae_Crack-V1: maps/tours/view/9967 +3 bonus
Kanon16-V2: maps/tours/view/9871 +3 bonus
Pincoletto-V1: maps/tours/view/9328
Metatron-V1: maps/tours/view/9594 +3 bonus
JAdmeal-V1: maps/tours/view/9979
Nebe-V1: maps/tours/view/9977 admitted with no bonus and -3 for late delivery
PLEASE ALWAYS SPECIFY THE VERSION OF THE ROUTE YOU VOTE FOR (1 or 2 WHERE AVAILABLE)
Software Engineer, Cycling Fanatic
- kanon16
- Spettatore
- Posts: 48
- Joined: 07/10/2016, 22:33
Re: Tour de France 2018 - Voting
FIFTH PLACE Arnorius-V1
Very good Tour! I like particularly the stage with cobbles in Orchies and the arrival in Port de Larrau. Maybe 8 high mountain stages are too much and the Col de l’Iseran in stage 11 is too far from arrival..
FOURTH PLACE Antoninvds-V1
I really like your two Tour, mostly the first. The last stage in the Pyrenees is beautiful! Maybe too many stages equal to the real race 2018..
THIRD PLACE RdZ1201-V1
Beautiful race, maybe the arrival in Nancy is complicated for the space and in general only one Time-Trial versus 7 high mountain stages gives the climbers a nice advantage..
SECOND PLACE Bocmanis82-V1
Really an excellent tour! I love the stage in Landerneau and in Gap!! Maybe 3 Pyrenees stages immediately after the ITT is too much! You could have taken away the second one or put a flat stage in the middle..Anyway the stage in Argelès-Gazost is also super!
FIRST PLACE Pincoletto-V1
My favorite Tour. The idea of the arrival in Le Mans circuit is great, I love also the cobbles stage in Cambrai and the stage 9 (Grand Ballon). The stage with Alpe d’Huez is exaggerated but brilliant and the one with the Ventoux is crazy! Anyway I think it's well balanced. Excellent work!
Very good Tour! I like particularly the stage with cobbles in Orchies and the arrival in Port de Larrau. Maybe 8 high mountain stages are too much and the Col de l’Iseran in stage 11 is too far from arrival..
FOURTH PLACE Antoninvds-V1
I really like your two Tour, mostly the first. The last stage in the Pyrenees is beautiful! Maybe too many stages equal to the real race 2018..
THIRD PLACE RdZ1201-V1
Beautiful race, maybe the arrival in Nancy is complicated for the space and in general only one Time-Trial versus 7 high mountain stages gives the climbers a nice advantage..
SECOND PLACE Bocmanis82-V1
Really an excellent tour! I love the stage in Landerneau and in Gap!! Maybe 3 Pyrenees stages immediately after the ITT is too much! You could have taken away the second one or put a flat stage in the middle..Anyway the stage in Argelès-Gazost is also super!
FIRST PLACE Pincoletto-V1
My favorite Tour. The idea of the arrival in Le Mans circuit is great, I love also the cobbles stage in Cambrai and the stage 9 (Grand Ballon). The stage with Alpe d’Huez is exaggerated but brilliant and the one with the Ventoux is crazy! Anyway I think it's well balanced. Excellent work!
- TimoNierop
- Spettatore
- Posts: 6
- Joined: 15/08/2017, 17:35
Re: Tour de France 2018 - Voting
FIFTH PLACE: Xiky-V1
A good Tour with some great mountain stages, but to much TT kilometres for my liking
FOURTH PLACE: Kanon16-V1
A very well balanced Tour de France. Just very good.
THIRD PLACE: Antoninvds-V1
I love the 3rd week. Super hard with different, less-used climbs.
SECOND PLACE: Pincoletto-V1
A great Tour de France with some great clims like Cirque de Troumouse, Mont Pilat & La PLagne
FIRST PLACE: Bocmanis82-V1
Extremely difficult Tour de France. Especially the last two weeks. A show will be garanteed with these stages.
A good Tour with some great mountain stages, but to much TT kilometres for my liking
FOURTH PLACE: Kanon16-V1
A very well balanced Tour de France. Just very good.
THIRD PLACE: Antoninvds-V1
I love the 3rd week. Super hard with different, less-used climbs.
SECOND PLACE: Pincoletto-V1
A great Tour de France with some great clims like Cirque de Troumouse, Mont Pilat & La PLagne
FIRST PLACE: Bocmanis82-V1
Extremely difficult Tour de France. Especially the last two weeks. A show will be garanteed with these stages.
- taaramae_crack
- Appassionato
- Posts: 56
- Joined: 04/11/2014, 19:58
Re: Tour de France 2018 - Voting
FIFTH PLACE: Arnorius-v1 -- I liked specially your first week, even though there are, for me, too many finishes for pure sprinters. The rest of the Tour isn't bad too, but there are too many mountain stages and most of them with top finish, some of them in passes where there's nothing in the top (Colombière, Madeleine, Larrau...). One of them is fine, but someone must pay the race
FOURTH PLACE: Belgian4444-v1 -- Something similar than Arnorius, but this time I miss something more for the sprinters, I see 4 stages + Paris, but two of them could have easily a different ending. Also I don't like finishes in Palhières and Tourmalet (to a lesser extent, as it's a mythical climb), even more when they have good options near for a more realistic and economical finish, because some village/ski resort would pay for the ending.
THIRD PLACE: RdZ1201-v1 -- Very well executed Tour, but, for me, there are too major mistakes: just one TT (and it's only 45 km, long, but not too many); and too hard mountain stages, even though most of them have courses that I really enjoyed.
SECOND PLACE: Bocmanis82-v1 -- Possibly the best balanced Tour of the contest, with some quite interesting stages. Despite this, the mountain is a bit monotonous, there are like 4 or 5 top finishes in quite long and steep climbs, and both Pyrenees and Alps "mountain blocks" hasn't any soft stage between the hard ones, so the riders might reserve for the last one and "smoke" (as we say in spanish, can't find a better word for it ) the previous stages of the "block".
FIRST PLACE: Chiumiento-v1 -- For me, the most varied of all the courses, and one of the best balanced too (even though I would like to see a bit more of TT, just 10-15 km more). Very well executed first week, maybe a bit soft, but well, the Tour I made is something the same, so nothing to object here . The only thing I didn't like, as I said to Arnorius and Belgian4444, the finishes in climbs like Palhières or Portet d'Aspet, where there is nothing but, maybe, a little bar/restaurant/hostel in its top and aren't too mythical passes, so there's an excuse to finish there. But I find the rest of it very nice, congratulations
FOURTH PLACE: Belgian4444-v1 -- Something similar than Arnorius, but this time I miss something more for the sprinters, I see 4 stages + Paris, but two of them could have easily a different ending. Also I don't like finishes in Palhières and Tourmalet (to a lesser extent, as it's a mythical climb), even more when they have good options near for a more realistic and economical finish, because some village/ski resort would pay for the ending.
THIRD PLACE: RdZ1201-v1 -- Very well executed Tour, but, for me, there are too major mistakes: just one TT (and it's only 45 km, long, but not too many); and too hard mountain stages, even though most of them have courses that I really enjoyed.
SECOND PLACE: Bocmanis82-v1 -- Possibly the best balanced Tour of the contest, with some quite interesting stages. Despite this, the mountain is a bit monotonous, there are like 4 or 5 top finishes in quite long and steep climbs, and both Pyrenees and Alps "mountain blocks" hasn't any soft stage between the hard ones, so the riders might reserve for the last one and "smoke" (as we say in spanish, can't find a better word for it ) the previous stages of the "block".
FIRST PLACE: Chiumiento-v1 -- For me, the most varied of all the courses, and one of the best balanced too (even though I would like to see a bit more of TT, just 10-15 km more). Very well executed first week, maybe a bit soft, but well, the Tour I made is something the same, so nothing to object here . The only thing I didn't like, as I said to Arnorius and Belgian4444, the finishes in climbs like Palhières or Portet d'Aspet, where there is nothing but, maybe, a little bar/restaurant/hostel in its top and aren't too mythical passes, so there's an excuse to finish there. But I find the rest of it very nice, congratulations
- emmea90
- Consulente tattico Continental Tour
- Posts: 901
- Joined: 17/05/2011, 15:47
- Location: Milano
- Contact:
Re: Tour de France 2018 - Voting
Final Ranking
Bocmanis82-V1 32
Antoinvds-V1 12
Pincoletto-V1 12
Laplaz-V1 11
Chiumiento-V1 10
Timonierop-V1 8
Kanon16-V1 7
Belgian4444-V1 7
Benoit.guillout-V1 6
Taaramae_Crack-V1 5
Arnorius-V1 5
Xiky-V1 4
JibiValverde-V1 4
JibiValverde-V2 4
Alfa-V1 4
Antoinvds-V2 3
DYDYDYDOU-V1 1
RdZ1201-V1 1
Emilio.Torre-V1 0
Mauro-V1 -1
DYDYDYDOU-V2 -3
Miere1985-V1 -3
Pontix-V1 -3
Xander66-V1 -4
Diego12Alpe-V1 -5
Benoit.guillout-V2 -7
Ded-Moroz-V1 -7
JAdmeal-V1 -7
Jaivar27-V1 -7
Kanon16-V2 -7
Metatron-V1 -7
Tomremn-V1 -8
Pereiroseleccion-V1 -9
Anthofou31-V1 -10
Anthofou31-V2 -10
Matklimmertje-V1 -10
Nebe-V1 -13
For the equal positions, the jury (mine) decision is to prize the route with higher scores (example, who got most time 6pts, then who got most time 4pts)
Bocmanis82-V1 32
Antoinvds-V1 12
Pincoletto-V1 12
Laplaz-V1 11
Chiumiento-V1 10
Timonierop-V1 8
Kanon16-V1 7
Belgian4444-V1 7
Benoit.guillout-V1 6
Taaramae_Crack-V1 5
Arnorius-V1 5
Xiky-V1 4
JibiValverde-V1 4
JibiValverde-V2 4
Alfa-V1 4
Antoinvds-V2 3
DYDYDYDOU-V1 1
RdZ1201-V1 1
Emilio.Torre-V1 0
Mauro-V1 -1
DYDYDYDOU-V2 -3
Miere1985-V1 -3
Pontix-V1 -3
Xander66-V1 -4
Diego12Alpe-V1 -5
Benoit.guillout-V2 -7
Ded-Moroz-V1 -7
JAdmeal-V1 -7
Jaivar27-V1 -7
Kanon16-V2 -7
Metatron-V1 -7
Tomremn-V1 -8
Pereiroseleccion-V1 -9
Anthofou31-V1 -10
Anthofou31-V2 -10
Matklimmertje-V1 -10
Nebe-V1 -13
For the equal positions, the jury (mine) decision is to prize the route with higher scores (example, who got most time 6pts, then who got most time 4pts)
Software Engineer, Cycling Fanatic
- emmea90
- Consulente tattico Continental Tour
- Posts: 901
- Joined: 17/05/2011, 15:47
- Location: Milano
- Contact:
Re: Tour de France 2018 - Voting
Final Ranking (Update)
I missed Kanon16 vote
The final ranking is so the following one
Bocmanis82-V1 36
Pincoletto-V1 18
Kanon16-V1 17
Antoinvds-V1 14
Laplaz-V1 11
Chiumiento-V1 10
Timonierop-V1 8
Belgian4444-V1 7
Benoit.guillout-V1 6
Arnorius-V1 6
Taaramae_Crack-V1 5
Alfa-V1 4
JibiValverde-V1 4
JibiValverde-V2 4
RdZ1201-V1 4
Xiky-V1 4
Antoinvds-V2 3
Kanon16-V2 3
DYDYDYDOU-V1 1
Emilio.Torre-V1 0
Mauro-V1 -1
DYDYDYDOU-V2 -3
Miere1985-V1 -3
Pontix-V1 -3
Xander66-V1 -4
Diego12Alpe-V1 -5
Benoit.guillout-V2 -7
Ded-Moroz-V1 -7
JAdmeal-V1 -7
Jaivar27-V1 -7
Metatron-V1 -7
Tomremn-V1 -8
Pereiroseleccion-V1 -9
Anthofou31-V1 -10
Anthofou31-V2 -10
Matklimmertje-V1 -10
Nebe-V1 -13
I missed Kanon16 vote
The final ranking is so the following one
Bocmanis82-V1 36
Pincoletto-V1 18
Kanon16-V1 17
Antoinvds-V1 14
Laplaz-V1 11
Chiumiento-V1 10
Timonierop-V1 8
Belgian4444-V1 7
Benoit.guillout-V1 6
Arnorius-V1 6
Taaramae_Crack-V1 5
Alfa-V1 4
JibiValverde-V1 4
JibiValverde-V2 4
RdZ1201-V1 4
Xiky-V1 4
Antoinvds-V2 3
Kanon16-V2 3
DYDYDYDOU-V1 1
Emilio.Torre-V1 0
Mauro-V1 -1
DYDYDYDOU-V2 -3
Miere1985-V1 -3
Pontix-V1 -3
Xander66-V1 -4
Diego12Alpe-V1 -5
Benoit.guillout-V2 -7
Ded-Moroz-V1 -7
JAdmeal-V1 -7
Jaivar27-V1 -7
Metatron-V1 -7
Tomremn-V1 -8
Pereiroseleccion-V1 -9
Anthofou31-V1 -10
Anthofou31-V2 -10
Matklimmertje-V1 -10
Nebe-V1 -13
Software Engineer, Cycling Fanatic